Episode Synopsis (from the official website):
The U.S.S. Enterprise and her crew are diverted by a signal from the former captain of the U.S.S. Enterprise on Starbase 11, and proceed to the call. When they arrive they find Captain Christopher Pike, who is severely crippled by radiation burns, confined to a moving chair and his ability to communicate limited to the answers "yes" and "no."While I rarely post the entirety of the episode synopsis, the Menagerie is a complicated episode and one that is more effectively (and easily) explained in the synopsis form than as a part of my discussion of the episode. In order to understand the Menagerie, it is useful to know the history behind the first Star Trek pilot, The Cage.
Unbeknownst to Captain Kirk, Spock abducts Pike on board the ship. Captain Kirk returns to the U.S.S. Enterprise with Commodore Mendez, and soon discovers that Spock has locked the ship's controls on a course set for the planet Talos IV — a planet to which a visit carries the death penalty. Forced by the extreme actions of the Vulcan first officer, the two convene a court-martial against Spock.
During the proceedings, from an unknown source, they watch the events that transpired when Captain Pike was in command of the U.S.S. Enterprise. They are shown Pike's initial contact with the Talosians, a race of beings eager to study human beings in their natural state, and who can provide illusions to make things appear exactly as they would like. The transmission relays Captain Pike's entire mission surrounding the Talosians and their bizarre experiments while holding him in a powerful cage. The Talosians are telepathic beings, able to dig deep into the memories to find whatever illusion will be most effective. They attempt to hold Pike captive until his passion and fury force them to release him.
As the proceedings end, the entire court-martial is found to be meaningless, a result of Commodore Mendez being an illusion created by the Talosians for Kirk's benefit. The events, as well, which depicted Pike on Talos IV were also found to originate from the Talosians.
Because of Pike's condition, Spock has risked his career and freedom to bring his former captain to a place where he will be able to live an illusion of a pleasant life, rather than the tragically limited one he lives now. Kirk allows Pike to beam down to Talos IV and all charges against Spock are dropped.
The Cage was the original pilot for Star Trek, filmed in November and December 1964 and never seen in its entirety on national television until 1988. While The Cage had most of the elements and ideas of what would become Star Trek, it was substantially different. The U.S.S Enterprise was captained by Christopher Pike, Spock was the science officer, and the ship's first officer was the rather mysterious Number One (played by Majel Barrett Rodenberry), and an entirely different principle cast. The pilot was rejected by NBC, but the studio took the almost unprecendented step of commissioning a second pilot, Where No Man Has Gone Before. The Cage might have drifted into obscurity had Gene Roddenberry not devised a clever way to help budgetary constraints with a two part episode that would be called The Menagerie.
Roddenberry crafted the story of the now crippled Christopher Pike and Spock's efforts to get him back to Talos IV and interspersed the episode with footage from The Cage to create the background story of Pike and Spock and to use as "evidence" in the trial. The idea was well received by the studio (and far ahead of its time) and The Menagerie was rushed into production.
Though episode takes place roughly 12 years before the events in Season One of Star Trek, and there are many inconsistencies between The Cage and later Star Trek that are difficult to reconcile cannonically. Spock displays far more emotion, the technology seems far more primitive, and the uniforms are substantially different from the final versions, and much more. The inconsistencies with Spock are difficult to explain, but can best be attested to the fact that Spock was very young for a Vulcan when he joined Starfleet and as a result of his half-human heritage he was still struggling with his Vulcan need to supress his emotions. The difference in uniform can be explained easily by the 12 year time difference, but it it harder to reconcile the much more primitive technology. Perhaps the Federation made an enormous leap forward in science and engineering in the 12 years leading up to The Original Series, much like the United States did in the 1960's.
The other issue that bears discussion is Spock's behavior. His actions in The Menagerie are irrational, at times illogical, and are atypical for his character. He essentially hijacks the Enterprise, lies to his captain and friend, violates standing Starfleet orders that are punishable by death, aids aliens in creating a mock trial to distract Kirk and the crew of the Enterprise, and generally acts emotionally rather than logically. While I have never liked this aspect of the episode over the years, I believe that with some suspension of disbelief you can reconcile Spock's actions in this episode with his behavior through the years. One of the things the trinity of characters in The Original Series have in common is their unwavering loyalty to each other. They are loyal to each other no matter the consequences throughout the series and 6 films. Kirk loses a son and a starship to save Spock. Spock stands with Kirk at trial when he bears no obligation to do so and saves Kirk and the Enterprise at the cost of his own life. McCoy is the emotional support for Kirk and even Spock to some extent, offering advice, support, friendship, and eventually serves as the living host for Spock's Katra. The three men are inextricably linked, and if we can understand and believe this, we can understand Spock's somewhat irrational loyalty to his first captain, a man who helped start his career in Starfleet, who stood by Spock and nurtured him, that helped him understand and deal with his humanity. While it is an imperfect explanation, it is also an entirely plausible one that Spock felt at least some of the same loyalty to Christopher Pike as he later would for James T. Kirk.
Regardless of the continuity issues and the concern with Spock's behavior, The Menagerie remains one of my favorite episodes and has been a fan favorite for the last 40 years. It was a clever, innovative way of giving viewers a look at what Star Trek might have been and reconciling that with what it became.
Continuity:
- The technology in The Cage is far behind that of The Original Series, so much so that it takes some suspension of disbelief to accept that the Federation made such technological advances in only 12 years.
- The uniforms are very different in the Cage, although this can be attributed to the 12 year time difference.
- Spock displays much more emotion than in later episodes and it is clear that his Vulcan character is not fully fleshed out.
- One character briefly mentions something about "recently breaking the time warp barrier." While his sentence was incomplete, we must take this to be in reference to achieving a higher warp factor than previously possible or discovering improved warp technology rather than indicating that the Federation just discovered warp speed. This would present huge continuity issues with other established Star Trek issues and make the entire premise of the episode difficult to believe.
Fun Facts:
- Number One, the first officer of the Enterprise, is played by Majel Barrett Roddenberry, who would later marry Gene Roddenberry.
- Spock's eyebrows are substantially different in The Cage.
- This episode was the first appearance of Orion's and Orion slave girls in the Star Trek universe.
No comments:
Post a Comment